SEOGEOKreativ Street

How to Choose the Best GEO Agency: Six Things to Test

|Ankit Singh

The best GEO agency for your business is the one that can show how AI assistants describe your brand today, explain why, and say plainly what it can and can't change. Generative engine optimisation (GEO) is a young discipline, so an agency's method and measurement tell you more than its place on anyone's top ten list.

Key takeaways

  • Run your own AI visibility baseline before you brief anyone. It takes an afternoon and makes every agency audit easier to judge.
  • Ask how an agency measures progress. A mention and a citation are different things, and AI answers vary from one run to the next.
  • Treat a guarantee of placement in ChatGPT or any other engine as a warning sign.
  • Check that GEO sits on sound SEO. AI engines mostly draw on pages that are already findable.
  • Meet the people who will do the work, and ask which outcome the agency is prepared to own.

What services should the best GEO agencies offer?

A GEO agency works on how AI engines such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google's AI Overviews find, understand and cite a brand. Those engines don't rank pages in a list. They pull sources, read them, check who else agrees, and write a single answer.

That leaves three areas of work. The brand has to be findable in the indexes AI draws on. Its content has to be clear and specific enough to quote. And what it says about itself has to be backed up by third-party sources the engines trust. We describe these in more detail on our generative engine optimisation page.

Much of this overlaps with good SEO, which is why so many SEO agencies now offer GEO. The useful difference is the unit of work. SEO focuses on improving website discoverability and organic search performance, while GEO builds on these foundations to improve how brands are discovered, represented and cited across AI-driven search experiences.

Run your own baseline before you brief a GEO agency

Most buyers meet GEO agencies with no evidence of their own, so the agency's audit becomes the only version of events. A simple baseline changes that conversation.

  1. Write 15 to 20 prompts a buyer in your category would ask. Include category questions, comparisons, "alternatives to" queries and problem-led questions. Save the exact wording and reuse it in every testing cycle, so any change reflects the engines, not your phrasing.
  2. Run each prompt in three or four AI engines, set to the geography and language your buyers use. Log the platform, the model or version where it is shown, the location and language settings, and the date.
  3. Record brand mentions and source citations separately: whether your brand is named, and whether your site is linked as a source. Then check whether the description of your brand is accurate, and which competitors appear and how they are described.
  4. Run each prompt three times per engine, in fresh sessions, and record how often you appear rather than whether you appeared once. Answers vary between runs. Repeat the full cycle a few weeks later with the same prompts, settings and number of runs.

This isn't a substitute for a proper audit. It gives you a reference point, and it shows you quickly which agencies have looked at your category and which are presenting a template.

What should you look for in a GEO agency?

Six things separate a GEO agency worth shortlisting from one that has renamed its SEO retainer.

What to testWhat good looks likeAsk them
DiagnosisThey ask what the business needs to change before listing deliverables"What would you want to know about our buyers before proposing anything?"
MeasurementA defined prompt set, run repeatedly across named engines, with mentions and citations reported separately"How do you handle the fact that answers vary between runs?"
SEO foundationsThey check crawlability, site structure and content quality before talking about AI"What would you fix on our site first, and why?"
Off-site authorityEarned mentions in sources buyers and engines already trust"Where would you expect us to be mentioned, and how would you earn it?"
ProofNamed clients, a timeframe, and honesty about what else was happening"What did the client do alongside your work that contributed to this result?"
PeopleSenior strategists who stay on the account"Who writes the strategy, and who do we speak to each month?"

Measurement deserves the most attention. A mention means an AI answer names your brand. A citation means it links to your content as a source. Both matter, but they come from different work, and a report that blends them hides more than it shows. Ask to see a real report, with the prompts, engines and dates visible.

Proof is the second place to press. AI visibility is hard to attribute. A brand that appears more often in AI answers may also have launched a product, earned press coverage or grown its sales team in the same period. An agency that acknowledges this is easier to trust than one that claims every gain.

Will the GEO agency own the outcome?

The six tests show whether a GEO agency can do the work. One further question shows whether it will stand behind it: which business outcome is the agency prepared to own?

Many GEO retainers are scoped as deliverables, such as audits, articles and reports. The agency is paid when the work is delivered, whether or not anything changes for the business. GEO makes that gap wider than usual. Measurement is still maturing and results take quarters, so activity is easy to count and progress is easy to blur.

An agency that owns the outcome agrees at the start what the engagement should move, such as share of citation for priority prompts or qualified inbound enquiries. It reports against that outcome and says what sits outside its control. Some link part of their fee to it, which is the plainest form of skin in the game.

Ownership also depends on reach. An agency that only advises relies on other teams to publish content and change the website. An agency that runs SEO and GEO, content and website management together can be held to the result.

In our view this question deserves as much weight as the six tests combined.

What are the red flags when choosing a GEO agency?

  • Guaranteed placement. Nobody controls what an AI engine outputs. An agency can make a citation more likely. It can't promise one.
  • An unexplained score. A proprietary "AI visibility score" is only useful if the agency can show how it is calculated.
  • GEO with no look at your site. If the proposal never mentions your existing pages, structure or technical health, it's probably a template.
  • Volume as strategy. Hundreds of AI-written articles a month add to the web's noise without giving an engine a reason to cite you.
  • Undated screenshots. A screenshot of a client appearing in ChatGPT means little without the prompt, the engine and the date.
  • Manufactured mentions. Seeding forums or review sites with planted accounts is a reputational risk, whatever it does for visibility in the short term.

How much does a GEO agency cost, and how long does GEO take?

GEO is usually sold as a monthly retainer, sometimes after a one-off audit, and published prices vary widely by scope and market. The structure of the fee matters as much as its size. A fixed retainer pays for activity. A baseline fee with a variable part linked to an agreed outcome gives the agency a stake in the result.

On timing, expect early changes in citations within months and durable category authority over quarters. That is our reading from client work, and it will differ by category. A sensible agency will tell you which signals should move first and agree milestones around them.

How Kreativ Street approaches GEO

Kreativ Street is a GEO agency, so read this section as our view of our own work.

We begin with an AI visibility audit built on real buyer prompts, run across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and AI Overviews. That gives a baseline for share of citation and shows the gap to the brands being named. The work that follows covers brand entity foundations, citation-ready content, off-site corroboration and prompt-by-prompt tracking, and we use the parts a client's situation calls for.

Three things shape how we work. The first is the model. We agree the outcome an engagement is meant to move, such as share of citation or qualified inbound, and our fee reflects it: a baseline fee, plus a variable fee linked to that outcome. The second is that we can run the practice end to end: SEO and GEO, content, and website management. Recommendations don't wait in another team's queue, and accountability for the outcome stays in one place. The third is execution rigour. AI visibility is built through careful, consistent work over quarters, which is what Slow Marketing means in practice.

We don't guarantee what an AI engine will say. We report share of citation, qualified inbound and category share of voice, and treat rankings and traffic as inputs.

We've done this work for companies such as Revfin, eMudhra and Ramco Systems.

If you've run the baseline above and want a second opinion on what it shows, talk to us.

Frequently asked questions

What is a GEO agency?

A GEO agency helps a brand become discoverable, citable and trusted in AI engines such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google's AI Overviews. Its work covers technical findability, content that can be quoted, and third-party corroboration of the brand's expertise.

What services does a GEO agency provide?

Most GEO agencies offer an AI visibility audit, brand entity and technical foundations, citation-ready content, off-site authority building and prompt-level tracking. The stronger ones also connect this work to SEO, content and the website, so recommendations get implemented rather than parked.

How is a GEO agency different from an SEO agency?

An SEO agency works to rank pages so that users click them. A GEO agency works to make a brand the source an AI engine cites when it answers for the user. The two are complementary, and many agencies offer both.

Can a GEO agency guarantee that my brand appears in ChatGPT?

No. A GEO agency can build the discoverability, content and authority that make a citation more likely, and track how often it happens. It can't control the output of an AI engine.

How do I measure whether GEO is working?

Track a fixed set of buyer prompts across named engines over time. Record mentions and citations separately, check that the brand is described accurately, and compare against competitors. Then look at whether qualified inbound enquiries move with it.

Should I hire a specialist GEO agency or ask my SEO agency to add GEO?

Either can work. What matters is whether the team can show a defined method for AI visibility, measure it credibly and connect it to your existing SEO. Use the six tests above with both.

How do you compare the best generative engine optimization agencies?

Give each shortlisted agency the same brief and your own baseline, then score them on the six tests above: diagnosis, measurement, SEO foundations, off-site authority, proof and people. Ask each to show a real report, and to name the outcome it will own. Rankings and award lists tell you far less than how an agency answers those questions about your category.

Ankit Singh

Author

Ankit Singh

Head of Brand Visibility

Ankit leads brand visibility at Kreativ Street, owning how brands get discovered and cited across search engines and AI engines. He writes and directs much of the agency's thinking on SEO, GEO and the future of discovery.

Contact Us

Share your details for our team to get in touch with you.

+91

Thanks for sharing the details!

Our team will review this and get back to you shortly.